Testimonials

We think that our food, service, and catering is exquisite—but don't take our word for it!


Costco Executive Business Member of the Month!
Costco Executive Business Member of the Month!

Here's what some of our customers have to say! Feel free to add your own comments!


Reviews from Google Maps

5 of 5 Stars Overall Rating

"Gotta try the Gyros and Pesto Chicken Pasta. They're awesome! "Best pizza and food in all of Orange County. CA. The owner Al is a great guy and he stands behind his food and service. You won't be disappointed."

"The pizza and gyros are my personal favorite, but everything we have tried at NYC Cafe has been excellent."

"We love the food at this place! The pizza is absolutely fabulous, especially with a greek salad on the side. The staff is very friendly - great customer service!"

"Best food and catering, wonderful service. Amazing food. We had a graduation party that turned amazing because of the great food we have had. Best Italian and Greek food in OC."

"They have the best thin crust anywhere! The staff is always friendly and if you call ahead it's ready when they promise (and if it's Friday or Saturday night , you SHOULD call ahead)."

"I go to NYC cafe at least twice a week. The Al's pastrami is out of this world, fresh pizza bread with melted cheese. And the Gyros are the most delicious gyros you can ever have."

Please give us a review on Google Maps!

Reviews from Yelp!

4.5 of 5 Stars Overall Rating

"I'm not normally in this area, but was here for work. I was looking for lunch and came across a sign pointing to the store that read "Gyros." I absolutely LOVE gyros. I wasn't expecting much since it was a very average looking place, but this was seriously the best gyro I've ever tasted, and let me tell you, I've tasted quite a few gyros in my 25 years of life. They bake the bread for all their pizza and gyros right there on the spot, and it was amazing. Great price for something so delicious. I yearn for that gyro and have even planned a trip back out that way JUST so I can taste it again. Great customer service, too. Awesome, awesome food with nice portions."

"The most amazing gyro ever. If you like hot pastrami this is where you need to go if your in town. The Al special is amazing, I like mine with mustard and you have to ask for it. Everything I've ever tried here is great. Keep it up guys."

Please give us a review on Yelp!